Monday 9 December 2013

Student topic for Wednesday

Hi, it's Ryo.
We're going to talk about this.

"Patient's right vs Doctor's power"

http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/newfoundland-labrador/dr-c-i-m-cheating-on-my-cancer-doctor-1.2453571

It says,
"we don't see the person we're treating."   "That person has free will"

My questions are like this.

"Which should be more respected, doctor's medical opinion or patient's free will??"

"Should doctors care every single patient's personality, feeling and other stuff?? Is that too much??"

"If someone is diagnosed with cancer, he or she is going to die anyway. Should we treat them even though we take their freedom away??"

"In Japan, we sign a lot of documents before surgeries to make sure that we're not going to sue doctors if something happens. Is that fair?? How about your country??"


I hope we'll have a good time!

3 comments:

  1. I feel like last question is interesting.
    see u.

    ReplyDelete
  2. "Which should be more respected, doctor's medical opinion or patient's free will??"
    If I have possibility I will be saved,
    I agree with doctor's opinion.

    Should doctors care every single patient's personality, feeling and other stuff?? Is that too much??"

    Too much..
    But If patients have a little possibility,every kinds of doctor should do that if patients have enough time to take care.

    "If someone is diagnosed with cancer, he or she is going to die anyway. Should we treat them even though we take their freedom away??"

    If they don't have possibility that they will be saved, we don't have to do that.
    But beforehand I will have to ask patients their ideas.

    "In Japan, we sign a lot of documents before surgeries to make sure that we're not going to sue doctors if something happens. Is that fair?? How about your country??"

    In this case, I have no choice. I will do that and I hope that doctor ability will save patient.
    If you doubt the doctor ability....
    Why don't you make new system that we can choose doctor who has good ability?


    ReplyDelete
  3. How am I supposed to know who is Naoko, Ryo, Shun and Nick? I'm confused.

    ReplyDelete